This week I had the honour of delivering a keynote address for the 2026 How We Survive symposium, alongside Andrew Rae, and Kate Brady. This is what I had to say:
Around 40 years ago, a rather thinner and brown-haired version of me used to carry around a battered TDKD90 cassette of Talking Heads Stop Making Sense. The music was like something we’d never heard before, complex, multilayer, poly rhythmic, fast paced, and obscure lyrics that didn’t really make sense. Sounds a lot like managing disasters. It also eminently danceable. It was an album that was used to get parties started in suburban Canberra in the early/mid 80s. It was my soundtrack to the times. To my eternal regret, I turned down a $27 ticket to the Stop Making Sense tour in 1985 because it meant I wouldn’t have eaten for 2 weeks. Not remorseful. At all.
Around this time, I was completing an honours degree in physical geography, but I was hanging out with a lot of human geographers, one of whom was examining the topic Topophilia, a concept developed by the Chinese-American geographer, Yi Fu Tuan. My friend was focusing on the connection of humans and the natural environment. I found this fascinating (I’d also taken an environmental philosophy unit), and this started shape my own thesis which became less about drilling holes in a catchment and trying to read the soil cores, and more about the human processes happening around the catchment. It was when I realised, maybe people are important, and led me to a nursing career.
Fast forward to 1999 and the full version of Stop Making Sense is released, and I was embarking in my disasters career. One of the tracks on this expanded version Naïve Melody really intrigued me, as it was out of character for their music. It was almost lullaby like. This line resonated.
Home is where I want to be. I guess this must be the place
I was probably at an age where I was more attuned to place (houses, babies). But I was also hearing these lines come up time and time again in conversations with people, after disasters
“I’ve lived here all my life”
“This is what we call home”
We built this house, this garden
“I moved here for the bush/coast”
“I think about this place all the time when I am away”
“I won’t see the bush like this again in my lifetime.
All the while I would hear from my agency colleagues.
“they were told and they wouldn’t listen”
“They shouldn’t be living there, its too risky”
“Why haven’t you rebuilt yet?”
There was a disconnect in what people were experiencing and how the system was responding. At that time, although I am sometimes not sure how much better it is now, the approach to managing disasters was very linear. See hazard, fix hazard.Our focus in disasters has been either try to engineer away the problems or throw a bit of relief to the problem and it’ll be OK. It felt a bit more complex than that.
I want to talk a bit on the factors that contribute to the complexity of the context of disasters. Disasters are, by and large, place based. The systemic nature of risk and consequence can cascade that impact far beyond the physical impact. They are the intersection of a hazard, and a vulnerable community, and the impacts will have a place component, either directly or indirectly. The vulnerability of the community comes from human decisions not natural processes. Humans make decisions to put people in harms way. This is why they are not natural disasters.
We have an increasingly better understanding the processes that go on inside of people heads and how people connect to each other (the psycho-social). The nurse in me is very interested in the psychosocial part. But we haven’t spent a lot of time thinking about how people connect to Country, places, houses, and objects and what this means for preparedness and recovery.
This is where the geographer in me started to think, there is something in this place business. Mum, Dad if you are listening, that degree wasn’t wasted after all. We geographers get super excited at the word place. It’s the lens through which we look at everything. Both my kids birth certificates have me as a geographer, rather than a public servant as a was at the time, which is way more interesting.
It’s not for me to talk about connection to Country, as this is for the original custodians of the lands to talk about. I am in awe though, of the complex concept that Country is that bends and warps my little Western scientific reductionist mind. The work of Bhiamie Williamson and the crew at NIDR is instructive in helping understand and elevate the concept of Country in the disasters context. Search it out.
But I am happy to talk about places and how they shape our lives, our abilities to earn income, be educated, live healthy lives, and be connected to each other. The lives we live in these places are heavily dependent on largely invisible and interconnected systems for the delivery of essential services when we need them (e.g. energy, water, food, finance, health and education services, transport, and communications). They are a source of hazard risk, whether it is of climatic or geological or human origin.
So the concept that the humanist geographers, and the environmental psychologists tussle a bit over is Place Attachment. (we geographers tussle over many topics trying to apply a discipline through a place lens, it makes us a little bit generalist). Yi Fu Tuan identified that “space” transforms into “place” as it acquires definition, value, and emotional depth through human experience. What I’m about to talk through relies upon the work of Charis Anton and Carmen Lawrence.
Place attachment gives places meaning. It is the cognitive bond people develop to where they live. Bonds with places can start young, however they can also develop quite quickly, if the place becomes meaningful to a person. Place attachment is generally a positive concept and as I have mentioned, can be described as topophilia, the love of a place. However, a negative attachment to place can also form to places if there has been a bad experience. These may be traumatic experiences, e.g. events like the Port Arthur Massacre, or stressful experiences. How many crime novels have an evil place?
These cognitive bonds can be described in terms of who is attached (either individually or community level), how are they attached (emotions, behaviours, thoughts), and what are they attached to.
Four factors influence place attachment, demographic, socioeconomic, spatial, and psychosocial. The demographic factors that are important are age and gender (older and women). The socioeconomic factors that are important are jobs, income, and home ownership. The spatial factors of location and rural/urban are important, and the psychosocial factors that are important are mental health and wellbeing positively influencing attachment.
Place identity (how we describe ourselves) and place dependence (what we draw from the land) are concepts that contribute to place attachment. Place identity is more symbolic. Places that make us feel unique, in control, good about ourselves, and are consistent with our ideas of who we are, are more likely to become part of someone’s identity. A country or city person, a mountain goat or beach bum, a suburbanite or inner city latte sipper. These identities can shape the actions people take and are seen to be important in planning for recovery. Place dependence is more utilitarian and the extent to which a location can meet an individual’s needs. This could be tangible i.e., someone earns their income from the land, or intangible, i.e., physical, or emotional wellbeing. This is particularly important in rural and primary industry communities.
So what does this mean for us? There is often little conscious thought given to places on a daily basis, but once it is under threat, then the sense of place attachment increases. We understand through the work of Douglas Paton and Julia Becker and others that a positive place attachment is associated with greater levels of individual preparedness. People are likely to have stronger attachments to homes rather than locations. We also know, however, it can also be associated with significant risk-taking behaviours in disasters, as people choose not to evacuate in the face of a threat, either downplaying the threat, or not wanting to lose their property. Surprisingly, loss and destruction can also strengthen place attachment, as people experience a grieving reaction for the lost landscape or buildings, as Peter Read’s magnificent book, Return to Nothing covers.
When a place is impacted negatively, a person can experience solastalgia, when an environment changes so much that it negatively affects an individual’s quality of life. Although a person’s recovery can also be positively influenced by the recovery of a landscape, as we found after the Black Saturday bushfires in the Beyond Bushfires research study
I briefly also want to talk about ontological security, a concept developed by the sociologist Anthony Giddens, which is the ‘confidence that most human beings have in the continuity of their self-identity and in the constancy of their social and material environments. That is, ti is having confidence in the routine and reliability of persons, places and things around them. These routines create a cognitive order and sense of safety and trust in the world; they function as a coping mechanism against existential anxiety, enhance psychological wellbeing, and provide a ‘protective cocoon and a ‘firewall against chaos’. The Joni Mitchell song Big Yellow Taxi, with the line “you don’t know what you’ve lost until its gone, the day they put up a parking lot” rings true here.
Homes are important in our lives, and their loss in disasters, can be traumatising. They help provide for a person’s identity and place in the world. This is known as ontological security, The way homes are designed and decorated, the objects within them, and gardens around personalises them, and contributes to this ontological security.
So what does this all mean, and how can I apply this.
- I think we need more research into the role that place attachment plays in decision making disaster risk reduction, disaster response and recovery.
- As you are building your contextual assessments, remember first Principle of recovery is understand your context, think about the role that place might be playing in people’s decisions about preparedness, about recovery.
- You could incorporate place attachment measures into community resilience assessments, into community recovery needs and impacts assessments to help you understand the depth of connection.
- Think about how you might incorporate that into public information sessions, whether its about preparedness, resilience building, relocation or recovery.Make sure you have people experienced in place attachment helping with your programming.
So in closing, while I mentioned I was remorseful about missing talking heads in 1985, as the world was closing in on us in January 2020, with my wonderful family, we saw David Byrne’s American Utopia in a small theatre in New York. Perfect.
Finally, hopefully, Once In a Lifetime rather than ignoring the Warning Signs and Burning Down the House, the Lady Don’t Mind if we don’t make Tentative Decisions and we examine the Puzzling Evidence, and so we ensure that Home, this must be the place is not on a Road To Nowhere, it is Heaven. Thank you.